philosophical answer to who are you

The most we can do is ascertain that we are indeed different, a compilation of our multiplicity: we are evolved animals; the inhabitants of earth; the most widespread of colonists, and the most diverse of species. Your name isn't you. Even if The Iliad has the same font, paper, and glue as El Otoño del Patriarca, they are different books because one is about a Greek struggle and the other a Latin dictator. Have a great time taking this who are you quiz and knowing the Real True You. How did the philosophers answer the question, “Who are you?” That isn’t a serious philosophical question. So for me, the ‘Who’ is the consciousness and the ‘What’ is the body. The problem is that, mostly we want to believe there is a core self or single I inside the sensations, so we can reinforce our Self Concept: “I am the sort of person who…” A fragmented self-concept is emotionally distressing. Eyes. Life and its activities is rotating the kaleidoscope, rather than me. In more extreme cases sufferers have been known to self-harm, acute pain creating a faster and stronger reconnection. Each of us must answer these questions for ourselves, but we can share our answers with others. Books have similar physical elements, like paper, binding, and ink. But once again the answer is wrong. At the end of the quiz we will give you the result. The two together make me a person. Possibly – so a soul, a consciousness. Enjoy and share. Being a person means that I am a social animal, needing connection, recognition and acceptance from others, while simultaneously knowing myself as isolated and solitary, with many experiences which are never fully shareable with others. When I am Friendly Human I am not Worker, focused on accomplishing a task. However, I also realise that this paradoxical condition is a universal experience, and this enables the emergence of empathy and compassion for others as it affords glimpses of understanding and solicitude, mutuality and intimacy. Anything else would be an abstraction that would liken me to others who share such characteristics. By knowing who you are, you realize the value you have to yourself and society. What is your Strongest Chakra? Are you a spiritualist or rationalist or conformist or anything else? Psychologists say that your experiences right from the early years of life shapes how you think, your decisions, actions, and your future. In each of these identities, however, I find two things: a state of interiority – feelings, thoughts, beliefs and desires with which only I am directly acquainted, and a social role – a relatedness to other human beings. It also means that I can never provide a genuinely definitive answer to the question. This quiz is a project for my History of Philosophy class. I have roles to play in life, but I am not any of them. Discovering Your Passions Think about what you loved as a kid. This has enabled humans to develop complex means of social interaction. Why do we dream? However, whatever answers that you ultimately accept as being true will predominantly determine your identity and beliefs. I adopt a stance toward others of smiling, looking at them rather than averting my eyes, nodding and saying “Hello” and so forth. There isn’t an ‘I’. You are a giver and a nurturer, strongly involved in your community, and a natural people person. But, as with a real kaleidoscope, this means opening up and getting inside, which we mostly resist. If you want a chance of getting a signed book, please include your physical address. If you look in the mirror, what is staring back at you? If I were like most humans I would carry that thought even further, and think that I was either the pinnacle of evolutionary development or the crowning achievement of a divine being’s creation, only slightly less divine than the supernatural being who created me. Philosophers generally agree: without an absolute God to make the rules, there is no such thing as a moral absolute; there are only preferences. It also favors order rather than chaos. This 10-minute personality test will assess you based on your underlying thoughts on how you view life and how your thoughts affect the decisions you make. This site uses cookies to recognize users and allow us to analyse site usage. The first-person point of view is an important starting point. I see the Self as a kaleidoscope. However, there is another aspect of me not directly visible or definable. 10. If you think you answered incorrectly, you can always go back to any question and change your answer. As psychosynthesis says, I’m a collection of sub-personalities. The little time left over which we could call ‘time out’ is scarcely enough to keep up with what happens in the world around us, if we even are interested. That is, the events and objects surrounding it, and its actions on, reactions to, and perceptions of them. You’ve probably thought of a few such questions when you were in pain or when you just made an uncomfortable realization. 3. Competitor feels tense, anxious and angry. study guide by yardi94 includes 41 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. She enjoys helping people to achieve their greatest dreams and ambitions by sharing valuable tips based on personal experiences. Does fate exist? Would love your thoughts, please comment. Philosophy : who are you? I am still looking for what Martin Heidegger called ‘Being’. I am a material or physical being fairly recognisable over time to me and to others: I am a body. In the absence of absolute morality, power reigns supreme; the strong survive and the weak get exploited. It is not meant to be simple but quite challenging. philosophers, psychologists, academics, scientists, artists, theologians and politicians have all tackled the subject of identity. Thanks for contributing an answer to Philosophy Stack Exchange! It is however an error to conclude that the body is not significant for selfhood. Because of all that, I think myself superior to a mouse. Subject lines or envelopes should be marked ‘Question Of The Month’, and must be received by 25th July. I am a linguistic phrase in the novel of time. A philosopher would want to start from the most fundamental premise they can, and establish from there. You don't actually have a right to live; you just prefer not to die. Submission implies permission to reproduce your answer physically and electronically. And when we look in the mirror, to question ourselves and stare at our flesh, our eyes, our bones, our blood, to philosophise and obey our brains – in short, when we define ourselves as human, that is what it is to be a person. The ability to examine one’s own experience is something that distinguishes us from other animals. An identity, he called a “soul”. The 9 Different Types of Intelligence – Which Smart are you? Who You Are And Your Values Philosophy Essay. Not capable of devouring huge quantities of texts on Descartes’ cogito, Freud’s ego, Proust’s ‘true me’, Sartre’s ‘non-essence’ or Locke’s personal identity, I choose a different approach, related to a condition I have had since my teenage years: depersonalisation. The first scenario is when a stranger asks you, “Who are you?” Without a blink, you will answer, “Who am I? Traditional questions include the following: How can we know that the ordinary physical objects around us are real (as opposed to dreamed, or hallucinated, as in the Matrix)? I’m here to do as best I can: my watery, grainy, languagey part of the story society is constantly creating about what it means to be alive. The 3 Big Questions of Philosophy We need to return to the big questions of philosophy. It includes deference and yielding. The situation is comparable to that of a book. The Hotel Infinity paradox aims to explain the concept of infinity. It seems that assigning a particular identity to someone else occurs through a process of observation, watching and remembering a person’s actions, then placing a value on the information we have of that person from our past and present encounters. What are the factors that determine whether a belief is rational or irrational? So I cannot say “I am.” I can only say “This thing I call Myself is like the image in rotating kaleidoscope” and “I am a Crowd.”. In the Many Selves model all these Selves are interrelated, actors with a script they write as the play proceeds, with more parts than actors, so multiple roles are played. Here’s ‘who are you quiz’ to help you know who you are inside. The prize is a signed copy of the book. Except on this theory there isn’t a ‘myself’ at the core, this I-ness is the constant flux. I’m a crowd, so I’m a ‘what’. Is there a meaning to life? To a degree I can add or remove bits of glitter, choosing colour and shape, such as changing my behaviours and attitudes. Is it possible to live a nor… By contrast, Friendly Human is peaceful and relaxed but a bit reserved: I am not anxious, angry or hostile, but neither am I completely unguarded. Being a person means that I am like all other persons, but also unique. This is the picture I have of myself. I’m a book. © Philosophy Now 2021. You’ve read one of your four complimentary articles for this month. We are often inclined to believe that the face we see in the mirror is us, a thing which has developed a personality through experiences. When I am in a depersonalised state I know two things. We are not bound by chains of habit or instinct; we can see who we are and choose to change it. I work at….” In this case, your answer is shallow and brief, because you want to finish your interaction with the stranger pronto. In this way human culture advances far more rapidly than biological evolution. They pass, and I get to continue to meander as I wish. Answers. This means that I am a self plus a story. I am a living, breathing organism signified by the words ‘human being’. The idea is to know about your ideology and thinking pattern to help you understand how you see at things in a broader perspective. One way to find out who you are is to look attentively at the way you react to certain things, or the answer you have for certain questions. By giving your name you feel you've answered that question. I would argue that the answer to this question is dependent on the idea of identity. My very limited control is to speed it up or slow it down. Yet I have opposable thumbs and use language, narratives and imagination for almost everything in life. Who are you? This part of me is aware that I can never be fully known or understood by myself or by others; it notices that although there may be some unchanging essence which is ‘me’, this same ‘me’ is also constantly changing and evolving. Discussions inthis area do not always make clear which one is at stake. His bits are mainly red and angular – a spiky person; hers are mostly greenish and rounded, a softer personality. 6. 1030 words (4 pages) Essay. I am retired a long time already, and we all change considerably through the years. When I look at the mirror in the morning, the face which stares back at me is not me. The suggested answer is “ neti neta ” – “not this, not that.” In other words, you will discover who you are by realizing who (or what) you are not. It tells you which philosopher suits you best, so after taking the quiz you can read book. You follow a strict moral code in your life, and believe we are meant to help each other. “I am a fool!” cries the self, while the other labels that person a genius (or vice versa). Would you want to know you are going to die before hand or die suddenly without warning? Likewise, I am different from you because my story is about a guy from Edmond and yours is not. Their hypotheses are … The question that stands is, are you up for the challenge? I am today what I established yesterday or some previous day.”. Is it, with Plato and Aristotle, the ability to reason and live virtuously? 9. I keep to myself, engaging others briefly if they wish, or not at all. For example, if you ask, “Am I my body?” you can come up with any number of arguments to support a ‘No’ answer. As with the Gestalt and the Many Selves models, the pattern is ever changing. The Philosophical term ‘identity’ is a relational term, specifically, a relation that x and y stand in, just in case they are the same thing, or identical to each other. There are two scenarios to this question. Are you or is something holding you back from who you really are? The following personality test asks you some simple short questions like do you have a soul or do you think the universe is real and so on. Western philosophy is clueless. So here is a description of who I am in particular contexts. Usually, when philosophical questions are asked, it is not with the hope that an ultimate or final answer can be reached but it is asked with the hope that at least some partial understanding can be gained from the series of answers that can be provided. From my collection I create a story, and with my opposable thumbs and language skills I share it. By giving your name you feel you've answered that question. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. and How do I function in a social context? How will humans as a species go extinct? The constant ‘me’ I wake up as is the kaleidoscope briefly at rest before the environment begins to turn it. The choices you make will define who you are When people say “i didn't have a choice”, their lying….. Words used to describe this aspect include ‘mind’, ‘spirit’, ‘heart’, ‘soul’, ‘awareness’ and ‘consciousness’. In this way I experience myself, others and the world around me. Answer Save. Human beings are defined by a sense of personality, experiences and reason. You can read four articles free per month. But then, what makes us different from animals? People who know their worth can make a good contribution to their own life and the world. A common technique for getting back in is to list the five senses and write what you are experiencing for each one, hopefully reconnecting yourself with yourself in the process. Let us know what truth is and what it’s good for in less than 400 words, please. In the same way that Einstein showed that time is dependant on viewpoint, so I think we can show that identity is relative, and by extension, the answer to the question ‘Who or what am I?’ becomes a matter of who is answering it. But that’s not who I am, that’s what I am. For instance, the claim that a book at time t1 is the same book at time t1+1 is an identity claim. Philosophy is about generalities, but this question demands particularity: who am I – a particular person in a particular time and place, related in particular ways to others? The Gestalt view is similar: I/This is the continuous interaction and interrelatedness between myself and the environment of others and objects. Someone else on the other hand might want to kill you regardless of how you feel about it, and who is to say that they're wrong? What’s new every time is the mood I wake up in or experience. I step aside when encountering someone on a narrow path. I follow his idea about Dasein. The second is an external creation of identity, formed by someone else. Hotel Infinity. I want to answer your question by paraphrasing the originator of Psychosynthesis, Roberto Assagioli: I have emotions, but I am not my emotions. Being a plumber, a school teacher or a clerk is a role that you play. I am a part of everything, but I am not in charge of everything, and that’s a relief. You, me, the creepy guy down the hall – we all have similar selves, but I’m a one-of-a-kind story. To answer this question requires gaining some perspective on oneself. Bones. When I am Intimate, my guard is down; I delight in things my mate does; I let my thoughts and words flow freely; I bask in the warmth of love. The question ‘Who am I?’ can be answered only specifically. Here the body is merely a tool for the true self, the mind. When I walk in the park, I am Friendly Human. These are the pictures that other people have of me. The difference between you and I here manifests in the fact that I presume you voted my answer down, whereas I simply left you with the 0 that your answer deserves (on THIS site). Where is the line between art and not art? The idea of identity is itself rather problematic in that it’s determined from subjective viewpoints, which can be divided into two types. By letting them pass, I avoid confrontation and disharmony. By comparing stories, we find such timeless human themes as love and hate, honor and degradation, loyalty and betrayal, inspiration and despair; and we learn how others have handled themselves in situations without ourselves having to undergo them. Do not think about the answers too long. I am neither an angel nor a monster. In basic courses in philosophy you might hear statements like 'Basically, you can … By taking an ‘objective’ point of view toward our own subjectivity, we can transcend ourselves. Differences between people are simply different combinations of different bits. Even if I had a Siamese Clone we would still have different selves because he would perceive the world from a different viewpoint than me. 8. What harsh truths do you prefer to ignore? Half of our lives we behave like animals. When you are self-aware you can indulge more in self-learning rather than blindly accepting what people say. From this I can deduce that there are two entities present, the conscious and the physical, and the link that connects the two is sensation. A short answer to the title of your question is: Asking the question 'Why?' It is perfectly likely that our one defining feature is metaphysical. Sufferers regularly experience autoscopy, more commonly known as an out-of-body experience. Philosophical questions are those you can’t answer using science but rather help you think about what you know or believe to be true. We bet you will find out important things about yourself which you never knew before. Most of the rest of our available time is spend doing what the societies we live in want us to do, namely work to earn enough to pay for those necessities. Your perception creates your reality. What if you're asked: "Who are you?" – Personality Quiz, What Is Your Subconscious Mind Obsessed With? To celebrate the launch of Mark Vernon’s book How To Be An Agnostic (Palgrave Macmillan) the next question of the month is: What is Truth? 10 Answers. Your thoughts create your world. Throughout the history of mankind, the subject of identity has sent poets to the blank page, philosophers to the agora and seekers to the oracles. Is humanity headed in the right or wrong direction? It is important to know who you are as an individual because self-awareness is the path to inner peace. If you leave the job, you won't cease to exist. Our view of our own identity places the highest priority on the intentions and thoughts that precede our actions, in contrast to other people’s reliance on our actions. Perhaps what we really are comes down to the rather annoying answer, “we are human.” But ‘human’ describes something that we cannot certainly define or grasp. But once again the answer is incorrect. Towards that end I am a thought collector, and I hoard ideas and experiences like a mouse hoards cheese. You constantly see the greatness and the beauty in humanity. So, what makes a self particular? If this is so, why don’t I know the face in the mirror? There are limits to what we can make of ourselves imposed by evolution, biology and culture, ut the ability to know those limits and find ways to work within them gives us the unique ability not only to discover, but to decide and create the answer to the question ‘Who am I?’. The mind/brain utilizes the body to survive, calculate and function within various social contexts. They cannot be our identity since identity is something that must be consistent over time. I am basically good, but I am capable of evil. What is the difference between knowing something and just believing it? And like mice I am also made of water and soil. Intimate feels best of all. Picture a hotel in … The usual answers are not of much philosophical interest: Bill, Patricia’s husband, Katy’s father. I am so and so. What is the best way for a person to attain happiness? More accurately, this thing is a collection of personalities, some shy, some noisy, pushy, sexy, boring, clever. Acquisitor feels much like Worker, but when combined with Competitor, feels hostile. Your thoughts create your world. 5. X. I am a grain of sand on a beach. Someone’s personalidentity in this sense consists of those properties she takes to“define her as a person” or “make her the person sheis”, and which distingu… 4. But higher mammals’ intelligence is too near ours to assume this is our single differentiation: the ability to communicate and love is reflected in dolphins and primates. I am not Competitor, focused on getting somewhere ahead of someone else. This is for the philosophical essay that i am writing and posting this question is a way of gathering opinions about the topic I am going to write. You believe in the inherent goodness in all people, and seek to do good for others. I’d like to end with a Joyce quote, which could shed more light on the problem than I have: “I am tomorrow, or some future day, what I establish today. It cannot be me, it is too old to be me. I get more enjoyment from the path by letting others have it. The question must then be asked, on what do we base these identities we assign other people or ourselves? Are you a spiritualist or rationalist or conformist or anything else? When you apply for a job as a teacher, you may be asked about your teaching philosophy.This is not the sort of question you should fumble or improvise on the fly. Take just now this quick and easy quiz and find out who you are based on your answer to the world's greatest philosophical questions! We each have a life-story, of what has been and continues to be important to us, what the pivotal events were that brought us to the present moment. However, personally, I think none of those grand thoughts. Are you really who you said you are? When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. If so, what is it? What does it mean to live a good life? The 4 Types of Introvert: Which One Are You? If so, do we have free will? Here are themost familiar: Who am I?Outside of philosophy, ‘personalidentity’ usually refers to properties to which we feel aspecial sense of attachment or ownership. Cynthia Evans is an intuitive spiritual blogger, enlightening and empowering people with her blogs on spirituality, energy work, self-love, spiritual wellness, healing, mindfulness, self-development and so on. 2. f you enjoyed this free, online and insightful quiz then share it with your friends. So I am a physical body and an emotional and psychological (or spiritual) being. I am a particular self. Every move and decision you made in life says who you … This is the Many Selves model. To have complete access to the thousands of philosophy articles on this site, please. Does the study of philosophy ever lead to answers or simply more questions? So it is equally likely that being human comes down to our biological structure – our DNA and physiology – developing certain features that other animals lack, including hormones. Did we nail it? and trying to answer it without saying 'Just because! Sleeping, feeding, drinking, pursuing sex and other bodily necessities, we do exactly what baboons, monkeys, and other animals do. Blood. Not literally, of course, but this is the metaphor that I’m going to use, so please bear with me. I am just Friendly Human – a bit like a dog, but with more autonomy. I am a “ha!” in the middle of a long belly laugh. 11. And underneath that? You are you because you have lived your life, and I am me because I have lived mine. There is no single problem of personal identity, but rather a widerange of questions that are at best loosely connected. The body runs on the mind’s residuum. The array of physical sensations available to me also includes pain, hunger, thirst, tiredness, injury, sickness, fear, apprehension and pleasure. This can mean that the person we consider ourselves to be may not be the person we portray to others. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. We have, in some measure, the ability to create ourselves. I am not Acquisitor, focused on getting what I want. The automatic response is to give your name. Flesh. Posted Mar 04, 2016 based on Your Answer to The World’s Greatest Philosophical Questions? There is philosophical interest in this only to the extent that it illustrates the human capacity to adopt strategies for being in the world, and thereby define our own answers to the question ‘Who am I?’. The philosopher John Locke argued that momentary thoughts are not consistent and change over time. What if you're asked: "Who are you?" Thank you for those who will answer. What should be the goal of humanity? The philosopher Rene Descartes suggested that our mind and thoughts are our true identity. How would you answer this question in a Philosophical way?-----This isn't a homework. Nor am I Intimate, focused on loving, understanding and enjoying my mate. Amy Adkins illuminates Plutarch’s Ship of Theseus. These murky waters of abstract thinking are tricky to navigate, so it’s probably fitting that to demonstrate the complexity, the Greek historian Plutarch used the story of a ship. The first is an internal creation of identity, formed by myself for myself. 7. When people say “i didn't have time” there, their lying too, people always have a choice, it's just their priorities that matter. You are you because you have lived your life, and I am me because I have lived mine. But that’s not the w… I share a large genetic similarity with mice. Philosophy. An important aspect of this story about stories is that the story exists independently of me. I am a water molecule in an ocean. You can share it with your friends :) I call it an evolutionary process; but still, this face I see does not correspond with what I feel I am. Is free will real or just an illusion? Second, as mentioned, I know that to reconnect I must experience a physical sensation, painful or pleasurable, the more intense the more effective. Friendly Human is a strategy for being in the world which avoids hostility and harm. The kaleidoscope’s glitter are the few fixed aspects of me, such as gender, body, culture, etc. You’ll look unprepared for the job if you don’t have a ready answer. All rights reserved. Thus we are physical beings capable of having non-physical thoughts that in turn construct and sometimes deconstruct the physical world. Through my body, I can move, touch, see, hear, taste and smell. In the light of this, philosophy is all about justification. And these thoughts are more comfortable, less stressful views of me than grand visions of me as the center and purpose of everything. Who Are You? Its story. Without a body a mind would not be able to make certain types of judgments. Where does your self-worth come from? For instance, if you loved to color, … What makes them unique is the story that they contain. But these answers are not right. If you’re beginning to ask yourself the profound question, “Who am I?,” then you’re probably tapping into what the ancient Hindu sage, Adi Shankara, explained is the third layer of existence — after the subtle thoughts of the mind and the intellectual layer — your perfectly pure and divine self. The mind governing our body assigns mental places to various objects in the world. But are we still the same person if we suffer from some degenerate disease, mental or physical? Even living 50% of the time as an ape, I nevertheless feel the facticity of living in space and time, and have always tried to be authentic in my acts and the thoughts which motivate them, seeking an independence of mind and avoiding the general entrapment of following the crowd in the search for the Being of beings. This is the aspect of me which thinks and feels, reflects and judges, remembers and anticipates.

Can Dogs Eat Turkey Necks Cooked, Block Party App, Hymns About Serving Others, Original Rubiks Cube Egypt, Coconut Oil Lube Pregnancy, Winsor And Newton Series 7 Hobby Lobby, Saveg Cafe Yelp, Simple Guitar Chords, Swing Compressor Vs Scroll Compressor, Can Cats Eat Banana Baby Food, Is Vagabond Finished, Chicken Powder Slang,

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top